Up to Canon 1DsII index

Canon 1Ds mark II signal-to-noise ratio at mid-grey, as a function of ISO speed

Method

The target was a white board lit uniformly. A 200mm lens was used at a distance of 1.5m but focussed at infinity; hence the target was heavily defocused in order to obscure any non-uniformities of the board. The camera was put on aperture-priority at f/11. This aperture was chosen because a larger one tends to spread out the signal across the camera's histogram.

The camera was set to write 12-bit raw files and all in-camera noise reduction options were turned off. The raw files were processed in such a way as to extract the numbers (referred to as DN for data number) without any alteration. The raw file was split into its red, green and blue components, but no Bayer interpolation (or 'demosaicing') was done.

Two shots were taken at each ISO setting from 50 to 3,200. Each shot produced a narrow spike in the centre of the camera's histogram.

The first shot of each pair gave the mean value of the signal. The two shots were then subtracted and the standard deviation of the difference calculated. The noise is that figure divided by the square root of 2. These calculations were done on a 200 x 200 pixel crop from the centre of the images.

The purpose of the subtraction is to remove, as far as practicable, variations in the signal due to non-uniformity of the target or its lighting, spatial non-uniformity of the sensor response, or dust on the sensor. All of these would be the same for the two shots and are therefore removed upon subtraction.

Results

The average signal at ISO 100 was 466, compared to a maximum possible green signal of 3,711 for the 1DsII. Thus the signal was about 12.6% of full scale, in terms of linear raw DNs. Loading the raw CR2 file into Adobe Lightroom showed that it did indeed produce a spike at the centre of Lightroom's histogram, thus confirming that the 1DsII's metering was correct.

As one might expect, the signal becomes more and more spread out as we move to higher ISO settings, not only in terms of its standard deviation but also in terms of the minimum and maximum DNs.

The graph shows the signal to noise ratio against ISO speed. The red, green and blue components are shown separately.

This is slightly clearer if we plot the speed in stops rather than ISO values:

The S/N ratio at the highest speed of ISO 3,200 is 16 for the green and 14 for the red and blue.

The top speed on the Canon 1DsII is not a 'real' one but is obtained by exposing at ISO 1,600 and doubling the DNs in firmware.

What does the noise look like?

I loaded the CR2 files into Adobe Lightroom and developed them using its default settings, except that luminance and chroma noise reduction and sharpening were set to zero. The point curve was set to medium contrast. Below are 100% crops from the centre of the images.


ISO 50

ISO 100

ISO 1,600

ISO 3,200

Data table

© Peter Facey, Winchester, England
20080316 originated